The AGW models are a result of the
human psyche, what the evolutionary psychiatrist J. Anderson
Thomson describes as "We have a great deal of difficulty seeing
anything other than human causation" [1]. In other words, we
have a need to explain everything as 'caused by humans'. Applied
to climate changes: "It
must
be human-caused"
This is a general form of a 'conspiracy'. Instead of thinking
that things happen because they happen, humans have a need for
an explanation of things. What Taleb in his book The Black
Swan [2] calls the need of a narrative. In case this
explanation is human-caused, we can call it a conspiracy.
While generally speaking, people consider a conspiracy when it
was intentional cause (and preferably also hidden), the state
of mind that comes up with these explanations is in all cases
similar.
As an example, in another research, presented by Scientific
American [3], Timothy
Melley in his book “The Empire of Conspiracy”, explains these effects.
People see conspiracies everywhere. They even agree to
contradictory conspiracies simultaneously. Like Saddam
Houssein is dead and alive at the same time. Interestingly,
the same contradictory approach is also used for the
conspiracy of the human-caused climate change. Believe it or
not, because of Global Warming, Europe recently both warmed up
and cooled down at the same time[4]. In fact, anything that
happens is explained by AGW. That is because the people are
generally convinced that there is a conspiracy (in the general
meaning of the word) and anything is a sign of this
conspiracy, as nicely explained by Melley.
[1]: Richard Dawkins, The
God Delusion, p.172
[2]: Nassim Nicholas Taleb, The Black Swan, The Impact of the
Highly Improbable, 3rd ed. (2011), Allen Lane, ISBN
9781846145650
[3]:
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=moon-landing-faked-why-people-believe-conspiracy-theories
[4]:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2013/mar/25/frozen-spring-arctic-sea-ice-loss
For more information, contact me at The University of The
Algarve,
Prof. Peter Stallinga